Rice Genomics and Genetics 2015, Vol.6, No.5, 1-10
          
        
        
        
          4
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          ൌ
        
        
          ߙ
        
        
          
        
        
          ߩߚ
        
        
          ௧ିଵ
        
        
          
        
        
          ߛ
        
        
          ܶ  ∑
        
        
          ߜ
        
        
          
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          ௧ି
        
        
          
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          ୀଵ
        
        
          (1)
        
        
          Here,
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is the rice price series being investigated for
        
        
          stationarity,
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          is first difference operator,
        
        
          ܶ
        
        
          is time
        
        
          trend variable,
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          represents zero-mean, serially
        
        
          uncorrelated, random disturbances, k is the lag length;
        
        
          ,ߚ ,ߙ
        
        
          ߛ
        
        
          ܽ݊݀
        
        
          ߜ
        
        
          
        
        
          are the coefficient vectors. Unit
        
        
          root tests were conducted on the
        
        
          ߚ
        
        
          parameters to
        
        
          determine whether or not each of the series is more
        
        
          closely identified as being I(1) or I(0) process. The
        
        
          test statistics is the t statistics for
        
        
          ߚ
        
        
          . The test of the
        
        
          null hypothesis of equation (1) shows the existence of
        
        
          a unit root when
        
        
          ߚ
        
        
          ൌ 1
        
        
          against alternative
        
        
          hypothesis of no unit root when
        
        
          ߚ
        
        
          ≠ 1. The null
        
        
          hypothesis of non-stationarity is rejected when the
        
        
          absolute value of the test statistics is greater than the
        
        
          critical value. When
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is non-stationary, it is then
        
        
          examined whether or not the first difference of
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is
        
        
          stationary (i.e. to test
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          ௧ି
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          ௧ିଵ
        
        
          ~
        
        
          I(1) by
        
        
          repeating the above procedure until the data were
        
        
          transformed to induce stationarity.
        
        
          The Philips-Perron (PP) test is similar to the ADF test.
        
        
          PP test was conducted because the ADF test loses its
        
        
          power for sufficiently large values of “k” which is the
        
        
          number of lags (Ghosh
        
        
          
            et al.
          
        
        
          , 1999). It includes an
        
        
          automatic correction to the Dickey-Fuller process for
        
        
          auto-correlated residuals (Brooks, 2008, Mafimisebi
        
        
          and Thompson, 2012). The regression is as follows:
        
        
          ݕ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          ܾ
        
        
          
        
        
          
        
        
          ܾ
        
        
          ଵ
        
        
          ݕ
        
        
          ௧ିଵ
        
        
          
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          (2)
        
        
          Where
        
        
          ݕ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is rice price series being investigated for
        
        
          stationarity,
        
        
          ܾ
        
        
          
        
        
          and b
        
        
          1
        
        
          are the coefficient vectors
        
        
          ܽ݊݀
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is serially correlated error term.
        
        
          
            3.2.3. Testing for Johansen Co-integration (Trace
          
        
        
          
            and Eigenvalue tests)
          
        
        
          If two series are individually stationary at same order,
        
        
          the Johansen and Juselius (1990) and Juselius (2006)
        
        
          approach can be used to estimate the long run
        
        
          co-integrating vector from a Vector Auto Regression
        
        
          (VAR) model of the form:
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          
        
        
          
        
        
          ୀఈା
        
        
          ∑
        
        
          
            Г
          
        
        
          ݅
        
        
          ିଵ ୀଵ
        
        
          ∆
        
        
          ௧ିଵ
        
        
          
        
        
          Π
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧ିଵ
        
        
          
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          (3)
        
        
          Where
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is a nx1vector containing the series of
        
        
          interest (rice price series) at time (t)
        
        
          , ∆
        
        
          is the first
        
        
          difference operator,
        
        
          
            Г
          
        
        
          ݅
        
        
          and
        
        
          Π
        
        
          are
        
        
          nxn matrix of
        
        
          parameters on the
        
        
          
            i
          
        
        
          th and
        
        
          
            k
          
        
        
          th lag of
        
        
          
        
        
          ௧,
        
        
          
            Г
          
        
        
          ݅ ൌ
        
        
          ൫∑
        
        
          ܣ
        
        
          
        
        
           ୀଵ
        
        
          ൯
        
        
          ₋
        
        
          ܫ
        
        
           ,
        
        
          Π
        
        
          ൌ ൫∑
        
        
          ܣ
        
        
          
        
        
           ୀଵ
        
        
          ൯
        
        
          ₋
        
        
          ܫ
        
        
           ,
        
        
          Ig is the
        
        
          identity matrix of dimension g,  is constant term,
        
        
          ߤ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is nx1 vector of white noise errors. Throughout, p
        
        
          is restricted to be (at most) integrated of order one,
        
        
          denoted I(1), where I(j) variable requires
        
        
          
            jt
          
        
        
          h
        
        
          differencing to make it stationary. Equation (2) tests
        
        
          the co-integrating relationship between stationary
        
        
          series. Johansen and Juselius (1990) and Juselius
        
        
          (2006) derived two maximum likelihood statistics for
        
        
          testing the rank of
        
        
          Π
        
        
          , and for identifying possible
        
        
          co-integration as the following equations show:
        
        
          λ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          ሺ
        
        
          ݎ
        
        
          ሻ ൌ െܶ ∑
        
        
          ܫ
        
        
          ݊ሺ1 െ
        
        
          ୀାଵ
        
        
          λ
        
        
          
        
        
          ሻ
        
        
          (4)
        
        
          λ
        
        
          ௫
        
        
          ሺ
        
        
          ݎ ,ݎ
        
        
           1ሻ ൌ െܶInሺ1 െ
        
        
          λ
        
        
          ାଵ
        
        
          ሻ
        
        
          (5)
        
        
          Where r is the number of co-integration pair-wise
        
        
          vector,
        
        
          λ
        
        
          
        
        
          is the eigenvalue’s value of matrix
        
        
          Π
        
        
          .
        
        
          ܶ
        
        
          is
        
        
          the number of observations. The
        
        
          λ
        
        
          ௧
        
        
          is not a
        
        
          dependent test, but a series of tests corresponding to
        
        
          different
        
        
          ݎ
        
        
          values. The
        
        
          λ
        
        
          ௫
        
        
          tests each eigenvalue
        
        
          separately. The null hypothesis of the two statistical
        
        
          tests is that there is existence of r co-integration
        
        
          relations while the alternative hypothesis is that there
        
        
          is existence of more than r co-integration relations. In
        
        
          this study, this model was used to test for; (1)
        
        
          integration between pair-wise price series in any two
        
        
          contiguous markets in the zone and (2) integration
        
        
          among the six price series taken together.
        
        
          
            3.2.4. Test for Granger-causality
          
        
        
          After undertaking co-integration analysis of the long
        
        
          run linkages of the various market pairs, and having
        
        
          identified the market pair that were linked, an analysis
        
        
          of statistical causation was conducted. The causality
        
        
          test used an error correction model (ECM) of the
        
        
          following form;
        
        
          Where,
        
        
          
            m
          
        
        
          and
        
        
          
            n
          
        
        
          are number of lags as determined by
        
        
          Akaike Information Criterion (AIC).
        
        
          Rejection of the null hypothesis i.e. that prices in
        
        
          market j does not Granger cause prices in market i (by
        
        
          a suitable F-test) for
        
        
          h
        
        
          = 0 for h = 1, 2 ….n and
        
        
          ߚ
        
        
          =0 indicated that prices in market j Granger-caused