Molecular Pathogens 2024, Vol.15, No.3, 142-154 http://microbescipublisher.com/index.php/mp 150 7.3 Lessons learned and challenges Several key lessons have been learned from these case studies. The importance of integrating molecular and field data to select and propagate disease-resistant pines is evident. Molecular markers linked to resistance genes, when validated through field trials, can significantly enhance the efficiency and accuracy of breeding programs. However, challenges remain. One major challenge is the genetic complexity of resistance traits, which often involve multiple genes and gene-environment interactions. This complexity can complicate the selection process and requires comprehensive genomic studies to fully understand the resistance mechanisms. The long generation times of trees pose a challenge for breeding programs, necessitating the use of advanced techniques like marker-assisted selection (MAS) and genomic selection to accelerate progress. Moreover, the variability in pathogen strains and environmental conditions can affect the consistency of resistance expression. For instance, some resistance genes may be effective against certain pathogen strains but not others, highlighting the need for continuous monitoring and evaluation of resistance traits across different regions and conditions. 8 Environmental and Ecological Considerations 8.1 Impact of transgenic pines on ecosystems The introduction of transgenic pines into ecosystems has the potential to impact both target and non-target organisms, influencing biodiversity and ecological interactions. For example, transgenic pines engineered for resistance to specific pathogens or pests may affect herbivorous insects and their predators. A study on transgenic poplar expressing pine genes demonstrated that these trees exhibited altered interactions with herbivores, with changes in insect density and diversity observed in field trials (Robischon, 2016). Moreover, the pleiotropic effects of transgenes, such as unintended changes in tree physiology or stress responses, can further influence ecological dynamics. Transgenic trees may also impact soil microbial communities. A study on Wollemi pine translocation highlighted that translocated trees recruited species-specific fungal communities, which played a critical role in their establishment and growth in new environments (Rigg et al., 2017). This finding suggests that transgenic pines, through altered root exudates or other factors, could similarly influence soil microbiota, potentially altering nutrient cycling and soil health. Transgenic pines can also affect soil microbial communities. Research in South Africa and Argentina has demonstrated that alien pines can significantly alter arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungal communities, leading to reduced fungal richness and altered community composition. These changes can influence soil health and nutrient cycling, with potential long-term impacts on forest productivity and sustainability (Gazol et al., 2016)(Figure 3). 8.2 Biosafety and regulatory issues The deployment of transgenic pines is subject to stringent biosafety and regulatory frameworks to ensure environmental and ecological safety. Regulatory considerations include assessing the potential for gene flow to wild relatives, the persistence of transgenes in the environment, and the impacts on non-target species. For instance, the case study on transgenic poplar in China, which involved monitoring gene flow from transgenic Bt poplar, found low probabilities of transgene drift and negligible ecological impacts, supporting the controlled use of such technologies (Zhang and Hu, 2021). Biosafety assessments often involve field trials to evaluate the environmental risks associated with transgenic trees. These trials are designed to detect unintended effects, such as changes in growth, reproduction, or interactions with other organisms. Regulatory bodies also require comprehensive risk assessments, including studies on gene stability, expression levels, and potential ecological impacts. The development and use of transgenic trees must comply with international biosafety protocols, such as the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, which governs the transboundary movement of genetically modified organisms.
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjQ4ODYzNA==