Bt Research 2015, Vol.6 No.1 1-8
            
            
              ISSN 1925-1939
            
            
              http://bt.biopublisher.ca
            
            
              4
            
            
              Table 2. Gene content of
            
            
              B. thuringiensis
            
            
              and
            
            
              S. frugiperda
            
            
              larval mortality.
            
            
              Isolates
            
            
              Genes
            
            
              Mortality (%)
            
            
              cry1Fa
            
            
              vip3Aa
            
            
              Chi
            
            
              I_10
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              94.55 ±1.50
            
            
              a
            
            
              I_17
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              90.65 ±4.60
            
            
              a
            
            
              I_9
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              89.07 ±2.71
            
            
              a
            
            
              I_15
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              87.50 ±6.63
            
            
              ab
            
            
              I_13
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              86.72 ±1.97
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_14
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              85.17 ±1.50
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_16
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              84.40 ±5.10
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_1
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              84.40 ±7.10
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_2
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              81.25 ±4.60
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_6
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              80.47 ±1.50
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_18
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              80.47 ±2.34
            
            
              abc
            
            
              I_12
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              73.42 ±2.71
            
            
              bcd
            
            
              HD125
            
            
              
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              71.87 ±8.74
            
            
              cd
            
            
              I_7
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              61.72 ±9.99
            
            
              d
            
            
              I_11
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              X
            
            
              60.15 ±13.03
            
            
              d
            
            
              alesti
            
            
              
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              41.42 ±7.14
            
            
              e
            
            
              I_8
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              28.92 ±1.50
            
            
              ef
            
            
              I_3
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              16.42 ±6.17
            
            
              fg
            
            
              I_4
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              12.52 ±3.83
            
            
              gh
            
            
              aizawai HD137
            
            
              
            
            
              X
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              10.95 ±4.69
            
            
              gh
            
            
              I_5
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              X
            
            
              2.32 ±0.78
            
            
              gh
            
            
              tenebrionis#
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              0
            
            
              h
            
            
              Check
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              -
            
            
              0
            
            
              h
            
            
              X indicates the gene(s) were amplified whereas – indicates lack of the gene(s)
            
            
              the chitinases exhibited the potential to increase the
            
            
              toxicity of the bacterium for the control of
            
            
              Spodoptera
            
            
              exigua
            
            
              (Hubner, 1808) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)
            
            
              larvae. Among the 70 strains tested, 38 exhibited
            
            
              toxicity, indicating their potential to be applied
            
            
              synergistically with other
            
            
              B. thuringiensis
            
            
              crystal
            
            
              proteins. Thus, the majority of isolates tested in this
            
            
              work were confirmed to produce chitinase, and the
            
            
              isolates containing all three genes caused the highest
            
            
              mortality, which suggests a possible synergy among
            
            
              the genes. The chitinase protein may have caused the
            
            
              partial digestion of the insect’s peritrophic membrane,
            
            
              which may have facilitated the action of the Cry1Fa
            
            
              and Vip3A proteins.
            
            
              Multiple binding sites for Cry1 toxins are present in
            
            
              many insects (Ferré et al., 1991; Luo et al., 1999;
            
            
              Hernández-Martínez et al., 2014). The results obtained
            
            
              by Luo et al. (1999) demonstrated that there are at
            
            
              least two union sites with high affinity for the Cry1
            
            
              toxin in
            
            
              S. frugiperda
            
            
              . The work performed by Sena et
            
            
              al. (2009) complemented the results of Luo et al.
            
            
              (1999) by demonstrating a union between Cry1Ab and
            
            
              Cry1Fa in
            
            
              S. frugiperda
            
            
              which reinforced the idea of
            
            
              competition for the sole union site in the gut. In
            
            
              relation to interactions with
            
            
              vip3
            
            
              gene, this work
            
            
              evaluated the competition between the
            
            
              cry1
            
            
              and
            
            
              vip3
            
            
              genes in
            
            
              S. frugiperda
            
            
              , demonstrating that it is
            
            
              possible to combine
            
            
              vip
            
            
              with
            
            
              cry
            
            
              . These isolates could